The Dual Edge of Constrained Supply
For homeowners who are not looking to sell or move, the persistent supply shortfall has a straightforwardly supportive effect on property values. Fewer new units entering the market means less competition for existing homes. Population growth — driven by immigration levels that have added hundreds of thousands of new residents to Ontario in recent years — continues to place upward pressure on prices when supply is constrained, as the Ontario Chamber of Commerce has observed.
But the supply squeeze cuts the other way for homeowners who want to move up, renovate, or draw on their equity.
Move-up options narrow. With fewer new homes being built, the inventory of move-up properties — the mid-range and upper-range homes that growing families typically transition into — remains thin. A homeowner whose property has appreciated may find that the next rung of the ladder has appreciated just as much, or that options simply are not there.
Renovation timelines stretch. Labour shortages in construction are among the most acute in Ontario, driven by demographic trends and heightened demand for skilled trades. When fewer new-build projects are running, some trades capacity is freed up — but it comes at a premium.
Construction costs have risen 51 per cent since 2020, according to the Association of Municipalities of Ontario. Wages in residential construction grew nine per cent in 2022 alone — well above the average for other industries.
Property tax pressure builds quietly. This is the connection most homeowners do not see coming. Municipalities fund growth-related infrastructure — roads, sewers, water systems, police stations — through development charges levied on new construction. When housing starts fall, development charge revenue falls with it. AMO calculates that without development charges, Ontario municipalities would have needed to raise property tax revenues by roughly 20 per cent in 2022 to fund the same infrastructure. That cost does not disappear when fewer homes are built. It shifts onto the existing tax base — which means current homeowners.